Salehian.com 647-325-5000

2877 McSherry Lane

559 - Cataract Road, Thorold, L0S 1E6

$1,699,000

Reduced $100,900 from $1,799,900

Photo 1 of 50Photo 2 of 50Photo 3 of 50Photo 4 of 50Photo 5 of 50Photo 6 of 50Photo 7 of 50Photo 8 of 50Photo 9 of 50Photo 10 of 50Photo 11 of 50Photo 12 of 50Photo 13 of 50Photo 14 of 50Photo 15 of 50Photo 16 of 50Photo 17 of 50Photo 18 of 50Photo 19 of 50Photo 20 of 50Photo 21 of 50Photo 22 of 50Photo 23 of 50Photo 24 of 50Photo 25 of 50Photo 26 of 50Photo 27 of 50Photo 28 of 50Photo 29 of 50Photo 30 of 50Photo 31 of 50Photo 32 of 50Photo 33 of 50Photo 34 of 50Photo 35 of 50Photo 36 of 50Photo 37 of 50Photo 38 of 50Photo 39 of 50Photo 40 of 50Photo 41 of 50Photo 42 of 50Photo 43 of 50Photo 44 of 50Photo 45 of 50Photo 46 of 50Photo 47 of 50Photo 48 of 50Photo 49 of 50Photo 50 of 50
  • 3+1 bedrooms
  • 3 bathrooms
  • 14 parking
  • 3500-5000 sq ft

Listed 130 days ago · MLS® X13438342

About this home

A rare offering that combines the timeless charm of a classic farmhouse with the comfort and efficiency of modern construction. Built in 2010 and set on over 5 picturesque acres surrounded by mature trees, this exceptional property offers a peaceful country setting just minutes from all the amenities of Fonthill. From the moment you arrive, the home's authentic farmhouse-inspired architecture, handsome brick exterior, and expansive front porch create a lasting impression. Thoughtfully designed and crafted using quality local materials, the home is rich in character while offering the conveniences expected by today's discerning buyer. At the heart of the home is a stunning custom kitchen featuring soaring 14-foot ceilings, exceptional millwork, and an inviting open-concept design that naturally draws family and friends together. The space is both grand and welcoming, perfectly suited for everyday living and entertaining alike. The main floor offers the convenience of a spacious primary bedroom, allowing for comfortable one-level living. Upstairs, two additional bedrooms are complemented by a versatile bonus room currently used as a sitting room/den, ideal as a home office, library, or potential fourth bedroom. A truly unique feature is the fully self-contained lower-level in-law suite with its own private entrance, providing outstanding flexibility for multi-generational living, extended family, guests, or income potential. Surrounded by nature and offering exceptional privacy, this beautiful property delivers the best of both worlds-tranquil country living with shops, restaurants, schools, golf, and everyday conveniences only minutes away. A distinctive home where craftsmanship, character, and lifestyle come together in a truly remarkable setting.

Details

Type
Detached
Style
2-Storey
Age
6-15 years
Size
3500-5000 sq ft
Lot
313.17 × 547.85 ft
Basement
Full, Separate Entrance, Apartment, Walk-Out
Garage
None
Kitchens
2
Property tax
$14,332 (2026)
Neighbourhood
559 - Cataract Road
Municipality
Thorold
Price per sq ft
~$400 (about the same as detached houses in Thorold)

Interior

Bedrooms
3 above ground + 1 below
Bathrooms
1 × 5-piece (main), 1 × 5-piece (second), 1 × 4-piece (lower)
Kitchens
2 (1 below ground)
Rooms
10 above ground + 6 below
Family room or den
Yes
Fireplace
Wood
Features
In-Law Suite, Water Softener, Water Purifier

Heating, cooling and services

Heating
Forced Air, Propane
Air conditioning
Central Air
Water and sewer
Septic

Building and exterior

Style
2-Storey
Exterior
Brick Front
Roof
Cedar
Foundation
Poured Concrete
Age
6-15 years
Faces
South
Outdoor
Shed, Garden Shed

Parking

Total parking
14
Driveway and parking
Private

Lot

Size
313.17 × 547.85 ft (irregular)
Acreage
5-9.99

More

Possession
TBD
Nearby
Wooded/Treed, Cul de Sac/Dead End
Cross street
Hwy 406 & Hwy 20

Rooms

RoomLevelSizeFeatures
KitchenMain6.39 × 5.48 m (21' × 18')Combined w/Dining, Combined w/Great Rm
Living RoomMain8.23 × 4.24 m (27' × 13'11")
Primary BedroomMain5.57 × 4.17 m (18'3" × 13'8")
LaundryMain2.65 × 2.15 m (8'8" × 7'1")
BedroomSecond4.42 × 2.94 m (14'6" × 9'8")
BedroomSecond4.42 × 3.33 m (14'6" × 10'11")
Family RoomSecond4.16 × 4.05 m (13'8" × 13'3")
KitchenLower7.41 × 4.49 m (24'4" × 14'9")Combined w/Living
BedroomLower4.5 × 4.42 m (14'9" × 14'6")
RecreationLower7.57 × 5.99 m (24'10" × 19'8")
LaundryLower3.24 × 2.71 m (10'8" × 8'11")

History of this address

1 earlier listing at this address, with sold and leased prices. Create a free account or sign in to see them.

Location

Location is approximate. See nearby homes on the map

Recent sales nearby

See what similar homes within 1 km sold for in the last year. Create a free account or sign in to see them.

The neighbourhood

Getting around Car-dependent

No subway, LRT or GO station within a short trip.

Within a 10-minute walk: no grocery stores, 0 cafés and restaurants, 0 parks.

Schools nearby

Elementary

  • St. Alexander Catholic Elementary School Catholic
    EQAO: Gr 6 reading 89%, math 54%    2.2 km

EQAO: share of students meeting the provincial standard (2024–25). Ontario average: Gr 6 reading 86%, math 51%; Gr 9 math 55%; literacy test 83%.

Closest schools, not school zones. Check which school serves this address with the school board before relying on it.

Who lives here postal area L0S

Owners / renters
87% / 13%
Median household income
$95,000
Average age
48
Children under 15
13%
Homes
83% detached, 1% high-rise
Commute by transit
0%
Population
60,409

Languages spoken most at home besides English: Spanish 0.4%, Mandarin 0.4%, German 0.4%, Polish 0.2%.

Flood and conservation No mapped hazard

Not inside a mapped flood plain or regulated area in Niagara Peninsula Conservation’s mapping.

Screening maps only. Ask the conservation authority for a property inquiry before relying on this.

Safety

Crime Severity Index for Niagara Region (St. Catharines) police: 54 vs 57 for Ontario (2025).

Police-reported figures for the whole police service area, not this street. Rates use the area’s resident population.

Distances are approximate. Places © OpenStreetMap contributors. Neighbourhood figures: Statistics Canada, 2021 Census. School results: EQAO via Ontario Data Catalogue (Open Government Licence – Ontario). Flood and regulation mapping: Niagara Peninsula Conservation open data. Crime Severity Index: Statistics Canada.

Living here

Commute

To Union Station (downtown Toronto): 65 km. Transit times · Driving times

Noise Nothing major nearby

No highway within 500 m, rail line within 300 m, or airport flight path nearby.

Distances from the map, not noise measurements. Visit at rush hour to judge for yourself.

Internet High-speed

50/10 Mbps or faster available here by cable, fibre or DSL (the federal high-speed target).

From the federal broadband map. Check exact speeds and providers for the address.

Roads, rail, airports and planned stations © OpenStreetMap contributors. Internet: Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada, National Broadband Data.

Listed by SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY CANADA.

Listing information provided by PropTx Innovations Inc. and TRREB; deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate by PropTx.

Similar homes nearby

See more in Thorold